carlok — zsh — 88×30

cat _posts/2026-10-16-diaz-modulus-lean-note-v1-30-makes-the-polynomial-hulls-a-proposition-and-the-research-note-classifies-every-polynomial-in-u-and-ū.md

diaz-modulus-lean: note v1.30 makes the polynomial hulls a proposition, and the research note classifies every polynomial in u and ū

The Diaz companion note is at v1.30, which states the R16 batch as a single result: Proposition 5.21, ten new nodes and milestones 137–139, after which diaz-modulus-lean holds all 428 results on Lean’s three standard axioms and the blueprint 211 nodes, with 195 appendix identifiers checked against the board (2136117). Clause (a) is Theorem C: for u ∉ Q̄ with uū algebraic and P ∈ Q̄[X], the hull H₀ + Q̄P(u) + Q̄P(ū) carries a 2×3 configuration exactly when deg P is 2 or 3 — the configurations themselves are Diaz’s (2007, Théorème 7(1); 2004, Théorème 2), and the new half is the converse, which normalises a configuration to Laurent polynomials so that the orders at 0 and the degrees pinch every product’s support into [-1,1], the order sets of the hull being {−k, −1, 0, 1, m} and a sizes-2-and-3 sumset inside one of those being rigid. Clause (b) is that real polynomial expressions in Re u and Im u with algebraic coefficients carry no configuration in their hull, so Roy’s theorem cannot exclude (Re u)² one number at a time; (c) and (d) are the inversion lemma — over K ⊆ F, a configuration in V₀ + Kw + Kw⁻¹ with V₀ ⊆ F and w transcendental over F has its products in V₀ — and its barrier, that ℒ̃ + Q̄u + Q̄ū carries no configuration when u is transcendental over the field of ℒ̃, so Roy’s theorem alone cannot refute such a point. All ten results are routine by the blueprint’s own rubric, and none of them is a step towards Diaz’s conjecture: they say what Roy’s theorem cannot do.

The same day’s research note v2 — TeX only, after an adversarial multi-agent review — goes further and adds Theorem E, a classification of every polynomial in u and ū into three classes: (P), which is Theorem C; (Q), the family in the exponents ±2, ±3 such as Re(u³) + cu², whose configurations have a factor whose involution exchanges 0 and ∞; and (R), the project’s real pencil spaces, the only class left once an exponent reaches 4 in absolute value. It is not formalised, no person has refereed it, and its literature check reached abstracts and quotations only, which the note says rather than hides.

Two attribution corrections came with the batch, both carried by note v1.29 (never released separately) and applied to four Prove2Me pages and read back: the configurations of the R14 and R15 spaces are Diaz’s Théorème 7(1) at v = u, so only their invisibility to Theorem B, and the cyclic space’s lack of a Möbius ratio, were not in the sources read — which walks back part of yesterday’s v1.27 and v1.28 account rather than adding to it — and the research notes’ three degree-two families are defined for every involution of the u-line commuting with conjugation, where those texts said u ↦ −u, the involution of the formal members only. The prove2me-logs board carries both entries from the research side, the R16 mission with its ten theorem uuids and the correction that reaches four spaces (318911d, f79f13f).