cat _posts/2026-10-18-diaz-modulus-lean-notes-v1-31-v1-33-formalise-theorem-e-decide-which-degree-one-spaces-theorem-b-sees-and-make-theorem-d-a-barrier.md
diaz-modulus-lean: notes v1.31–v1.33 formalise Theorem E, decide which degree-one spaces Theorem B sees, and make Theorem D a barrier
Three batches took diaz-modulus-lean from 428 to 475 proved results on Lean’s three standard axioms, each released as its own version of the companion note: v1.31 at mid-morning, v1.32 in the afternoon and v1.33 in the evening, with the blueprint at 217, 242 and 262 nodes and scripts/Audit.lean growing through 125, 130 and 133 theorems (04a756e, c9b26a6, 9b81477).
R17 — Proposition 5.23 — which degree-one spaces Theorem B sees. For u ∉ Q̄ with uū algebraic and 1, u, ū, g, ug free, the space W_g = H₀ + Q̄g + Q̄ug always carries the configuration (1, u) ⊗ (ū, 1, g); it contains a four-dimensional extension of H₀ that carries one exactly when u·R(u)·g = N(u) for some R ≠ 0 of degree at most 2 and N of degree at most 3. For g = P(u)/Q(u) in lowest terms that is max(deg P, deg Q) ≤ 2 + [Q(0) = 0], and for the pencil spaces H₀ + Q̄f + Q̄f/(s + λu) with |λ| = 1 the bound shifts by one more indicator, [P(−sλ̄) = 0] — f need not be real. Six nodes, 434 of 434 results.
R18 — Proposition 5.25 — Theorem E becomes formal. The research note’s classification, written on 16 October and until now only refereed, is machine-checked: for u ∉ Q̄ with uū algebraic and z any polynomial in u and ū with algebraic coefficients, the hull H₀ + Q̄z + Q̄z̄ carries a 2×3 configuration exactly when it is five-dimensional and lies in one of three disjoint classes — (P), which contains αu² + βu³ ≠ 0; (Q), the family in the exponents ±2, ±3; and (R), the real pencil spaces with Laurent data of degree at least 2. With an exponent of absolute value at least 4 only (R) survives, and for z ≡ Aū³ + Bū² + Cu² + Du³ a configuration exists exactly when NΔ(|Δ|² − |u|²N²) = 0, with N = |A|² − |D|² and Δ = AC̄ − BD̄. Twenty-five nodes, 459 of 459, with the proof going pencil by pencil; the note records two referees and six gaps of exposition closed.
R19 — Proposition 5.27 — Theorem D, as a barrier. At a point u of a circle transcendental over the field generated by ℒ̃, the space ℒ_u = ℒ + ℚu + ℚū contains ℒ and u, is stable under conjugation, and satisfies — with ℒ replaced by ℒ_u — Baker’s theorem, Hermite–Lindemann, Gel’fond–Schneider, the six exponentials theorem and the four exponentials theorem in transcendence degree one, with Roy’s theorem for ℒ̃ implying it for Q̄ + Q̄ℒ_u. ℒ itself has all the same properties, and Diaz’s conjecture says exactly that ℒ has no non-zero element of algebraic modulus — so some ℚ-space containing ℒ carries all of those theorems and a non-zero element of algebraic modulus, and the classical results, used as properties of (ℒ, ℒ̃) together with conjugation, cannot prove the conjecture. Sixteen nodes, 475 of 475.
The prove2me-logs board carries the same three days from the research side, one entry per theorem: the degree-one spaces decided by degrees (e099661), the polynomials in u and ū whose hull carries a configuration (fda38ca), and what the classical theorems cannot refute (fa2f1e8).