carlok — zsh — 88×30

cat _posts/2026-10-23-diaz-modulus-lean-theorem-f-settles-which-hulls-of-a-rational-z-carry-a-configuration-and-it-agrees-with-theorem-e.md

diaz-modulus-lean: Theorem F settles which hulls of a rational z carry a configuration, and it agrees with Theorem E

Two rounds on 23 October took diaz-modulus-lean from 475 to 503 proved results, each with its own version of the companion note: v1.34 with R20 and v1.35 with R21a, the blueprint running to section 10.154 of chapter 10 and the audit to 138 theorems (26a7aac, 8cf2a67).

R20 — Theorem F, for a rational z. Theorem NF (degree_two_configuration_normal_form) is the tool: a 2×3 configuration with a ratio of degree two in a five-dimensional space containing 1, u, 1/u forces the space into one of three normal forms, D1, D2a, D2b, proved without sheaves — the resultant is non-zero, 1 and J/q are free over Q̄(h), at most two values of λ are bad, and a 2×2 Jordan form finishes it. Theorem F (rational_conj_hull_two_by_three_configuration_iff) then answers the question for z rational in u with |u|² algebraic: in dimension 4 the hull span(1, u, ū, z, z̄) is exactly the circle point 1/(u − a) with a ā = |u|², which is Diaz 2007 Théorème 7(1) at v = 1/(u − a), and in dimension 5 it is exactly D1, D2a or D2b. Twenty-two nodes, 497 of 497.

R21a — the two theorems agree. laurent_conj_hull_configuration_shape_iff_class shows Theorem F’s three shapes hold exactly when Theorem E’s classes (P), (Q), (R) do — as a corollary of both theorems, not by deriving E from F — with the maps (P) → D2a, (Q) → D2b and (R) → D1. In the same round, degree_two_configuration_multiplier_space_eq identifies W ∩ h⁻¹W as the three-dimensional x₀ span(y), and candidate_rational_conj_hull_criterion_not_mem_logAlgTilde puts Theorem F to work: under Roy’s strong six exponentials theorem, at a candidate, F’s criterion gives z ∉ ℒ̃. Six nodes, 503 of 503, and a stale claim removed on the way — the Theorem C note had asserted a reduction to graded matrices that was never written out, and now says only that no rank-two graded matrix breaks Roy’s bound, with the reduction listed as open.

The prove2me-logs board carries the same day from the research side, one entry per theorem: which conjugation hulls of a rational z carry a configuration (ae2a145) and the agreement with Theorem E together with the corrected rank-two claim (6393065).